Thanks for the feed back, I understand that most people don't like AI, but like I said I am crap at art and its a free and easy resource. If you have any questions about mechanics of the game let me know.
The reason I don't like generative AI is the exploitative use of labor, which is definitely what anti-capitalism fights against, as generative AI openly steals from artists. At the core of anti capitalism is rejection of the pristine in favor of the honest, we'd rather see you do stick figures than use ai.
Thanks again for the input, if that is the only complaint about the game is the choice in art on a free to download and Public Domain game then the game mechanics must doing alright. The premise of the game must be alright.
Ok so, I am gonna be real with you chief. Ignoring the whole irony of using AI art on an anticapitalist game. I think the game would flow better if you simplify some stuff. I am not an expert game designer, but maybe cutting back on the pages of AI art and making it a one page RPG would make it a lot better. Not only that, but I also think the game could be easily improved by cutting a lot of the classes or explaining the mechanics better. I know we give 5e a lot of heat, but it's a really popular game not only for its brand recognition, but because it's a really well layed out game. You also rely too much on people knowing mechanics from other games instead of building up your own.
Look, you got a good concept for a game, but you should really try to make one thing work well in a game jam instead of being a jack of all trades but a master of none. Having read the game, I just think it really doesn't hold up well enough to be played. This is just a recommendation, and you can ignore it as much as you want, but you should study what makes a good jam game work. Look at stuff like crashing pandas or the last tea shop. Or heck, look at some video games from other jams like the winners from GMTK.
Sorry If I am being extremely harsh, but you really got a solid foundation here, I like the dice mechanics and the setting. And seeing it's your first jam work I think you should be proud, you made a game and that's a big achievement, most people don't even get to that. I know it might contradict what I said earlier but I actually want to see more of your work, if you are able to flesh out this game later or make even more games I would love to see them. First games Always are kind of weird and amateurish(which I think is what makes them unique) and you got a good game if you polish some stuff
(Also, no art, public domain or really simple art is always better than weird anime looking AI )
Thank you, I appreciate the honest input will look at the suggested games.
The mechanics are kinda based off of the Ironsworn system which is based from the Powered by Apocalypse system, and I know that many have not explored those systems very much. I do agree that to the mechanics should be clarified.
I am trying to improve art wise, it just felt so bare without anything just couldn't find anything that looked right. So yeah free and easy resource.
I don't feel you are being harsh because you put valid reasoning behind your opinion, and I can respect that.
I am working on something a little more in dept follows along similar mechanics, has no classes, a lot longer, no AI art (because looking for artist), and is a fantasy game. When I complete that I will be looking for your review.
Sounds really fun, keep making games and I will keep reviewing them. If you ever need to contact me personally you can talk to me through discord, my username is Zejbo,
Also, an artist can be an expensive endeavor, but I think you can probably get a lot of creative commons works that you can use. Games like cairn 1e only have that kind of art, and they look really good.TBH, my biggest worry if I were you, would be to not burnout and just keep working on the game, making games should be fun not only for the people playing them but the people making them.
Anyway, hope you have a wonderful day and if you ever need somebody to playtest or give feedback, just hit me up.
100% agree, and trust me I will not be over working, got a full time job and household to keep up, the game development is my fun time. I will shoot ya my Discord later.
← Return to game
Comments
Log in with itch.io to leave a comment.
America do not want color revoution!China also
Confused??? Color Revolution?
because i read you submit Fuck capitalism's PDF
Bummed to see AI art in an anti-capitalist event.
Thanks for the feed back, I understand that most people don't like AI, but like I said I am crap at art and its a free and easy resource. If you have any questions about mechanics of the game let me know.
The reason I don't like generative AI is the exploitative use of labor, which is definitely what anti-capitalism fights against, as generative AI openly steals from artists. At the core of anti capitalism is rejection of the pristine in favor of the honest, we'd rather see you do stick figures than use ai.
Thanks again for the input, if that is the only complaint about the game is the choice in art on a free to download and Public Domain game then the game mechanics must doing alright. The premise of the game must be alright.
not even gonna open the game to play it or download it with ai art my guy
Well, to each their own, have a nice rest of your day or night.
Ok so, I am gonna be real with you chief. Ignoring the whole irony of using AI art on an anticapitalist game. I think the game would flow better if you simplify some stuff. I am not an expert game designer, but maybe cutting back on the pages of AI art and making it a one page RPG would make it a lot better. Not only that, but I also think the game could be easily improved by cutting a lot of the classes or explaining the mechanics better. I know we give 5e a lot of heat, but it's a really popular game not only for its brand recognition, but because it's a really well layed out game. You also rely too much on people knowing mechanics from other games instead of building up your own.
Look, you got a good concept for a game, but you should really try to make one thing work well in a game jam instead of being a jack of all trades but a master of none. Having read the game, I just think it really doesn't hold up well enough to be played. This is just a recommendation, and you can ignore it as much as you want, but you should study what makes a good jam game work. Look at stuff like crashing pandas or the last tea shop. Or heck, look at some video games from other jams like the winners from GMTK.
Sorry If I am being extremely harsh, but you really got a solid foundation here, I like the dice mechanics and the setting. And seeing it's your first jam work I think you should be proud, you made a game and that's a big achievement, most people don't even get to that. I know it might contradict what I said earlier but I actually want to see more of your work, if you are able to flesh out this game later or make even more games I would love to see them. First games Always are kind of weird and amateurish(which I think is what makes them unique) and you got a good game if you polish some stuff
(Also, no art, public domain or really simple art is always better than weird anime looking AI )
Thank you, I appreciate the honest input will look at the suggested games.
The mechanics are kinda based off of the Ironsworn system which is based from the Powered by Apocalypse system, and I know that many have not explored those systems very much. I do agree that to the mechanics should be clarified.
I am trying to improve art wise, it just felt so bare without anything just couldn't find anything that looked right. So yeah free and easy resource.
I don't feel you are being harsh because you put valid reasoning behind your opinion, and I can respect that.
I am working on something a little more in dept follows along similar mechanics, has no classes, a lot longer, no AI art (because looking for artist), and is a fantasy game. When I complete that I will be looking for your review.
Sounds really fun, keep making games and I will keep reviewing them. If you ever need to contact me personally you can talk to me through discord, my username is Zejbo,
Also, an artist can be an expensive endeavor, but I think you can probably get a lot of creative commons works that you can use. Games like cairn 1e only have that kind of art, and they look really good.TBH, my biggest worry if I were you, would be to not burnout and just keep working on the game, making games should be fun not only for the people playing them but the people making them.
Anyway, hope you have a wonderful day and if you ever need somebody to playtest or give feedback, just hit me up.
100% agree, and trust me I will not be over working, got a full time job and household to keep up, the game development is my fun time. I will shoot ya my Discord later.
Let me know what you think I will also answer any questions you might have.